We have found and fedeproxy.eu is starting 🚀

Our project team is *very* motivated to do the right thing, and we need your input and help 🙏

We'll offer @activitypub federation between to provide seamless interop between repo's wherever they are hosted.

1st question: What's your preferred forge?












Other (please respond)

Boosts appreciated!

@dachary Your about-article reads like I need an account on every server I want to federate with? If that’s true, what is the benefit of using fedeproxy?

Or does a fedeproxy-user create all the issues / PRs / etc. on the remote server? If that’s the case, isn’t that gonna be confusing if half of the participants in a conversation have the same username and avatar?

@tastytea when forges do not implement federation, a proxy needs a user on every federated forge, indeed. It could either be users that you happen to control because you already have accounts on all of them. Otherwise fedeproxy needs to create an account for this purpose. It would be confusing if multiple users are merged into a single one, you are correct. Fedeproxy will need to create a different account for every federated users. Does that sound sensible to you ?

@dachary I don’t think fedeproxy could create accounts automatically, because of captchas. So I would have to create the account manually. At this point I could just use the remote forge directly. I don’t see the benefit in creating an extra step.

@dachary @tastytea @dachary IMO the most relevant question dachary could ask is what forges are most hated considering the goal is to liberate data. And for that, I put gitlab.com as the most hated & most useless since we must solve a CAPTCHA just to read existing bug reports. #Gitlab.com is the most inaccessible forge of all forges even pretending to be "public". It's the max security prison of all prisons.

@tastytea @dachary If fedeproxy.eu could get data out of that gitlab.com jail, it would have the greatest impact in terms of liberating inaccessible data.

@dachary @tastytea Since I can't file bug reports on gitlab.com, I find the corresponding pkg on Debian or Ubuntu bug trackers and file it there-- but then I get complaints because the bug should be reported upstream (where the pkg is jailed in github or gitlab.com). Plz consider solving that problem with fedeproxy.

@resist1984 @dachary @tastytea

Personally I feel that #gitlab is also the most likely to be acquired by another #bigtech player in the future. It is too juicy for them to let this be out there as an independent product.

If this indeed happens, my bet is on Amazon, as an extension to their whole AWS shebang.

@humanetech @resist1984 @dachary @tastytea Yes, it's only a matter of time before Gitlab exits and merges with one of the BigTech companies.

But the planet-brain question is why we always become so dependent on these corporate intermediaries. Are our development tools not deficient if we always have to rely upon sites like Github/lab to collaborate on software?

Also, I don't think returning to mailing list workflows is viable. We need to be doing something better.

Follow

@bob @humanetech @resist1984 @tastytea On the bright side there is progress. Twenty years ago (SourceForge / Savannah time) the problem was different: self-hostable forge software was difficult to install and the user experience was not great. Today we can build on quality forge software, establish a federation and free ourselves from centralized services.

· · Web · 0 · 2 · 1
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

This is a brand new server run by the main developers of the project as a spin-off of mastodon.social 🐘 It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!